Increasing awareness about canned lion hunting

The Blood Lions documentary crew recently hosted a media screening in Johannesburg. This film is part of a global campaign to bring an end to predator breeding and canned hunting industries.

South Africa is home to more than 6 000 captive-bred lions, with approximately 160 lion ranches in operation for the sole purpose of turning lions into profit.

The campaign provides information on canned hunting.

“I have been on this story since the late 1990s and it’s been a long, tough journey for a number of reasons. However, with the release of Blood Lions, I sense we have the best chance of bringing an end to the horrors of predator breeding and canned hunting,” said environmental photojournalist Ian Michler.

UK volunteer speaks out: Cubs hired for parties and events – Ukutula

British wildlife volunteer, Keeton Hill, shares his experience and findings after his time at Ukutula farm, South Africa.

In 2013 I volunteered at Ukutula, a supposed lion conservation centre outside of Brits, Pretoria, in South Africa. For 6 months afterwards, I spoke of how great the experience was, and about how much good Ukutula were doing. Several weeks after returning from South Africa, I saw a claim that they were involved in the sale of lions for hunting. Initially, I dismissed this claim. However, after seeing more accusations, I decided to do some research to prove these claims wrong. A year and a half later, I am still yet to do so. Instead, I have only seen more and more evidence that I actually volunteered at a farm largely suspected to be involved in the canned hunting industry.

The project was booked through an agency which specialises in volunteering and working abroad. I spent 2 weeks in South Africa looking after lions. At Ukutula, volunteers were told that the lions were removed from their ‘dangerous’ parents, and hand-reared instead for their own safety. We were then told that samples were taken from the 100+ lions on the farm for research purposes, and that where possible, older lions were released into the wild.

 During my two week stay, I noted several ways of doing things that I didn’t agree with. For example, there was no permanent staff member in charge of supervising the volunteers who were looking after the cubs. Upon arrival, volunteers were given a brief overview of how to care for them. As of that overview, it was up to the volunteers to decide between them who were to complete what tasks. Any authorisations or approvals were to be sought from the owners, who weren’t always available. This sometimes led to volunteers not knowing how to handle some situations, which then resulted in disagreements between volunteers. For example, some volunteers allowed young children to pet the cubs, whilst others didn’t. Some allowed guests to feed the cubs, others didn’t. There was also an occasion during which the powdered milk supply for the cubs ran out. It was a two hour wait before more was delivered. I also didn’t agree with the cubs being able to be hired for parties and events (which happened several times during my stay). Despite these things, I naively believed everything that we were told about the ‘research’ conducted at the park, and the lion ‘release’ program.

 After the accusations against Ukutula were made, and I started my research, it became clear that these claims of releases were simply not true, and that Ukutula was far from what it made itself out to be. I realised that it operated in exactly the same way as canned hunting farms are described as operating. These similarities included a constant stream of cubs being born (there were 9 under the age of 3 months whilst I was there, with more on the way), large groups of tourists petting the cubs throughout the day, walks with older lions, and promises of the eventual release of lions into the wild (of which no evidence has ever been provided).

 In order to build up a balanced and comprehensive picture about Ukutula, and find out as much about it as possible, I asked questions to a previous volunteer, a previous member of staff, and the centre’s current owner. I asked both the previous volunteer and previous staff member if they had any reason to believe that the suggestions regarding Ukutula being involved in the canned hunting industry were true. The volunteer told me that they no longer supported the centre, as they had heard several claims that lions were sold from the park (something which the centre themselves later admitted to). The staff member politely declined to comment. I then asked the current owner a series of questions, regarding why they bred so many lions, and when and where their lions are released. I was told that the centre had never claimed to release lions into the wild (which is simply not true, as myself and several other volunteers were told by the centre themselves that they do).

Since this initial realisation, it has only become more and more clear that the Ukutula lies to its volunteers and guests, has never released any lions into the wild, and that they are also more than likely involved in canned hunting. The farm admitted to moving at least 2 lions, Michael and Mandela, to zoos in the United States, and the whereabouts of several lions, such as Kevin, Kylie, Ricky, and Jenny, to name just a few, are now unknown. Attempts at finding out where these lions might be through asking members of the farms staff have proved unsuccessful, always resulting in rudely written replies, which avoid answering the question. For example, when asked the whereabouts of Kevin the lion, an Ukutula employee replied, “none of you(r) damn business”. When I questioned the farm using an alternative email address to my own, posing as a volunteer interested in working there, they admitted that “lions are relocated in different places”. When I asked, “doesn’t that mean that the people that you send lions to could then sell them onto hunters”, the farm replied that, with a supposed “monitoring system” in the planning, this should mean that they should be “able to react to that”, but “sadly it does not mean there is a 100% guarantee”. I have also since realised that the CITES database shows absolutely no record of any lions being exported from South Africa for release into the wild in any other country. However, what it does show, is mass exports for lion trophies, lion bones, and lion skin.

I have shared my findings and opinions with any volunteers who were at Ukutula with me, and continue to attempt to inform other people who have been to the farm, as well as people that I know personally, about the canned hunting industry. Unfortunately, many previous volunteers refuse to believe about the industry, and defend the farm, often insulting or ignoring the people trying to inform them.

As the canned hunting industry is entirely legal in South Africa, creating awareness and understanding of the industry is vital, as this is one of the only ways to fight against it. The more people who know about canned hunting, the better, as this lessens the amount of unknowing volunteers who believe themselves to be doing good, which then lessens the money that these farms receive. This is why Blood Lions is so important, as it could finally be the large scale exposure of canned hunting that is needed to educate people about the canned hunting industry, as well as maybe even changing the terrible fate of South Africa’s captive-bred lions.

Top European hunting organisation, Jensen Safaris, says I told you so…

In response to the recent PHASA statement, Jensen Safaris, voices their opinion on the canned hunting industry.

How does this change come about? 

 The background is a new film that was released in South Africa last week, with the title “Blood Lions” – a well-documented take on the dubious lion farming industry and what PHASA terms “the hunting of captive-bred lions” – you can view the trailer at this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-T86GCjCpus

I am particularly embarrassed about the many Scandinavians that have either willingly or by lack of knowledge, been taking part in the canned lion shooting, and it made me rather proud, when the Nordic Safari Club subsequently removed all South African lion trophies from their record book. SCI have been slow in their reaction, and even mobilised well-known writer Craig Buddington to glorify canned lion shooting in South Africa – probably because hunting ethics play a much less prominent role in the US.

The problem does however go much further than the issue of canned lion shooting – just recently a Danish client bagged a canned leopard during a hunt in the Eastern Cape (as well as a canned lion) – commenting to one of the PH’s that “the leopard did not look healthy”! You bet it didn’t! Free State and Eastern Cape outfitters particularly, buy up large numbers of trapped caracals from as far as the Limpopo Province, in order to sell them to their clients (one operator bragged about doing 16 such canned caracal hunts in one season), and canned crocodiles are being transported from crocodile farms and put in farm dams in areas where they would never occur naturally, and are subsequently sold per feet to overseas clients.

Not only has PHASA over the past years covered up for these deeds – they have been actively involved in promoting them, by circulating advertising from lion farmers to their hapless members. I’ve been personally banned from taking part in discussions on their Facebook page, because they did not tolerate any criticism, and I do not expect that to change at all. In fact I don’t even think they can be trusted to solve the matter – they are bound to try and think out some scheme, where a set of “ethical” rules are laid down for members, with no-one able or willing to implement such voluntary regulations. Recently even the Minister of Environmental Affairs attempted to defend the lion industry via an insert in the Sunday Times, and their department lacks both manpower and know-how to effectively put a stop to the canned lion shooting. The most effective way would be for overseas countries to ban the import of lion trophies from South Africa – a step already taken by the Australian government.

I’m convinced we’ve seen only the start of the punishment coming our way – with this film now being distributed internationally, we can expect legislation that will not only hurt the lion farmers and their unethical partners in the hunting industry – we will see legislation that will hurt all outfitters in South Africa, irrespective of whether they took part in this con or not. It was all so avoidable, if PHASA had put “moral before money” as the editor of the German hunting magazine Jagen Weltweit so rightly expressed it in an editorial. PHASA and the majority of their members permitted to let greed get the better of an otherwise respected industry, and they’ve done untold damage to the reputation of hunting in South Africa.’

Holger Krogsgaard Jensen – CEO Jenson Safaris www.jensensafaris.com

**************************************************

Blood Lions welcomes this critical insight and support and looks forward to working with more organisations such as this. It is clear that the overwhelming view being expressed around the world is that predator breeding and canned hunting are regarded as atrocities that no progressive thinking society should be sanctioning. Furthermore, all the conservation claims made by these operators are false and unsupported by the recognized conservation community. SCI, PHASA and the South African Government need to come to terms with this and start engaging in constructive ways.  We reiterate that the goal of the film is to bring an end to canned or captive hunting and the exploitative breeding of lions and other predators on farms across South Africa.